The Differences Between Vinyl vs Aluminum Fencing

Black aluminum gate kit

Vinyl and aluminum fences are popular among homeowners and businesses today. Despite both types offering a pleasant, modern aesthetic to your home, there are some key differences between the two in terms of strength, maintenance, and cost. Choosing between vinyl vs aluminum requires careful consideration to ensure you’re making the right choice.

What’s the Difference? Vinyl vs Aluminum Fencing

Aluminum fencing is a sleek, contemporary style of fence for a front or back yard. It can be used as a privacy screen, security barrier, decorative fence, or a normal, backyard fence. Made of aluminum, it’s durable, low-maintenance, and offers a modern look to any home.

Vinyl fencing is a type of fence that offers a similar aesthetic to wooden panels, but is stronger, longer lasting, and doesn’t require frequent repainting or staining to maintain its color.

Besides being made from different materials (vinyl vs aluminum), both types of fences have their differences in terms of style, durability, maintenance, privacy features, and aesthetics.

Which is Stronger?

Vinyl fencing is hardy, but it’s not as robust as aluminum fencing. Aluminum provides better strength, security, and protection against bad weather, animals, and intruders attempting to climb it.

Vinyl is strong, but it doesn’t perform as well in bad weather, like a windstorm. It can easily buckle if intruders attempt to scale it. Pets, animals, and playful kids can also damage vinyl fencing if too much pressure is applied.

Winner: Aluminum!

Which is Better for Privacy?

Both vinyl vs aluminum fencing offer privacy to a garden, as long as you choose the right design.

Most vinyl and aluminum fences have spacers to boost sunlight and offer a unique aesthetic. However, you can get tall vinyl fencing and aluminum fencing without spacers. Both of these offer the same amount of privacy to a front or back yard.

Winner: Draw!

Which is Less Maintenance?

Both vinyl and aluminum fencing is low maintenance, but aluminum is easier to manage long-term.

Aluminum fencing doesn’t need to be routinely painted or cleaned. It gets dirty during adverse weather, but only needs a hose down to make it appear brand new again.

However, vinyl fencing takes more work to prolong its lifespan and keep it looking nice. You’ll need to pressure wash it and clean it with manufacturer-approved chemicals to prevent mold, mildew, and staining.

Winner: Aluminum!

Which is Cheaper?

When considering vinyl vs aluminum fencing, you have to consider the ongoing costs of both designs, as well as the initial outlay.

Aluminum is often cheaper than vinyl in terms of initial outlay and ongoing maintenance. This is because aluminum is more durable and can last longer.

Vinyl fencing doesn’t always last as long and requires routine maintenance to prolong its lifespan.

Winner: Aluminum!

Which Looks Better?

Which looks better (vinyl vs aluminum fencing) depends entirely on your personal preferences.

Aluminum fencing is completely customizable. It comes in different styles, heights, and colors (including two-tone), and comes with fully bespoke spacings to change the privacy of your yard. It’s a contemporary fence design that offers a sleek, modern, and elegant look to a garden.

Vinyl fencing also comes in different colors and styles, but doesn’t offer the same contemporary look. Despite its sleek material, it looks like wooden fencing from a distance.

Vinyl is often considered a better option compared to wooden fencing because of its reduced maintenance, rather than having a prettier aesthetic.

Winner: Draw!

Conclusion: Vinyl vs Aluminum Fencing, Which is Better?

Choosing between vinyl vs aluminum fencing depends on what’s important to you. Overall, the benefits of aluminum fencing outweigh vinyl, making it the better choice universally.

Aluminum is stronger, cheaper, has less maintenance, comes in a range of styles, and offers more privacy. Vinyl has strength and durability, but is more expensive, offers less security, isn’t as strong, and requires slightly more maintenance to stay looking its best.

Ready to find your perfect fence? Explore our aluminum fence products today.

Blog Alumission
Written by: Alumission
Shopping cart
We use cookies to improve your experience on our website. By browsing this website, you agree to our use of cookies.


Fill out the details below and we’ll get back to you shortly!

Full Name(Required)